Skip to content

Conversation

@ChainsofWarNFT
Copy link

  • Name: Chains of War
  • Description: Fantasy saga that carves a new world on the Cardano blockchain by means of storytelling, artworks, 3D assets and gamification.
  • Link: https://chainsofwar.io/
  • Tags:
    • game
    • nft

chainsofwar

@fill-the-fill fill-the-fill added the showcase Indicates a PR/issue on showcase label Jul 8, 2022
@ChainsofWarNFT
Copy link
Author

Hi @fill-the-fill

Thanks for adding the showcase label.
Are there any further instructions?

Best regards,
The Chains of War team

@fill-the-fill
Copy link
Collaborator

Hi @fill-the-fill

Thanks for adding the showcase label. Are there any further instructions?

Best regards, The Chains of War team

@aarondunnington hi, at the moment the next step is to receive 3 approvals from the community. Sometimes it takes time to review the projects, but you're on a right track. :)

Copy link
Collaborator

@rphair rphair left a comment

Choose a reason for hiding this comment

The reason will be displayed to describe this comment to others. Learn more.

I reviewed the web site which has plans to use the NFT collection eventually in a gaming platform. As I understand it they don't have a functional game and NFT holders are given a framework of characteristics that they can use to improvise their own games, lacking a functional metaverse or integration with other platforms.

I think that puts it into the same category as the 8 other projects that are listed with both tags nftproject and game, i.e. NFT collections intended for gaming who haven't got to the functional / integration part of their roadmap. Because of Cardano's slow progress I think this limitation applies to pretty much everybody now.

The one thing distinctive relative to what's already there now is the artwork, which is visually stunning: far beyond anything we already have on the Portal. The engagement on their Twitter feed suggests that people are looking forward to using this & that the demand for a more dynamic use of Cardano will be there when the metaverse integrations all start to proceed together.

So rather than tell this project "wait until your game is functional, then apply again" (which would be inconsistent with already listed projects who don't have functional games yet either), I'm going to vote for it & leave it for quorum to decide. If we don't get the other votes within whatever time frame is normal, then I'd look forward to the project applying again ASAP after they have a functional game & metaverse integration. 😎

@ChainsofWarNFT
Copy link
Author

Hi @fill-the-fill is there anything we can do to get this merge proposal approved?

@fill-the-fill
Copy link
Collaborator

fill-the-fill commented Sep 6, 2022

Hi @fill-the-fill is there anything we can do to get this merge proposal approved?

I've just noticed you are missing the preview image. Please add one to the showcase folder where all of the showcase images are being stored 🙂

@rphair
Copy link
Collaborator

rphair commented Sep 6, 2022

@fill-the-fill I missed that one too. Somehow between the OP inline preview image & the committed JS file my brain registered the submission as complete 🤪

@rphair
Copy link
Collaborator

rphair commented Sep 11, 2022

@katomm is this showcase image file within the size constraint suggested in #720 (comment)? It would be the largest image in the showcase by a good margin.

@katomm
Copy link
Member

katomm commented Sep 27, 2022

Personally, I'm struggling to see how this is a showcase for the developer portal. (but this is just my opinion)

What is more important: I don't think it's a good idea to accept more NFT projects at this time without further discussion of how we handle NFT projects in general. Anyone, please feel free to join the discussion here: #243 (We don't seem to be making any progress here because many people only seem interested in advertising.)

@katomm
Copy link
Member

katomm commented Dec 1, 2022

Thank you for your contribution and for building on Cardano. This PR has been open for quite a while and I would like to give you a little feedback. Projects need 3 reviewer approvals and it seems the project didn't get enough "traction" among the reviewers. 

Please note that showcase projects need to provide a unique value from existing showcase items - which is especially difficult with many tokens and FT/NFT or FT/NFT platforms. Feel free to join the discussion here: #243 (or in case you prefer to discuss this not in GitHub please join https://discord.gg/Exe6XmqKDx)

@katomm katomm closed this Dec 1, 2022
Sign up for free to join this conversation on GitHub. Already have an account? Sign in to comment

Labels

showcase Indicates a PR/issue on showcase

Projects

None yet

Development

Successfully merging this pull request may close these issues.

4 participants