Skip to content
Closed
Show file tree
Hide file tree
Changes from 1 commit
Commits
File filter

Filter by extension

Filter by extension

Conversations
Failed to load comments.
Loading
Jump to
Jump to file
Failed to load files.
Loading
Diff view
Diff view
Prev Previous commit
Next Next commit
FIX-2336: Teammates lab's lead becomes Chief of Staff, and acts inste…
…ad of offering

The lead worker is now chief-of-staff (teammates.chief-of-staff), shown as
Chief of Staff. Its WORKER.md gains general tool-use guidance: act rather than
offer, ask a teammate now when asked about them, hand work to whoever fits, and
ask the user only what no tool can find. It adds no project text. researcher
and writer each get a line saying who they are. README, TEAM.md, tests and the
two teammates-lab goals follow the rename.

Co-Authored-By: Claude Opus 5.5 <noreply@anthropic.com>
Claude-Session: https://claude.ai/code/session_01NczDiCsRqCenZsFQRpJBHi
  • Loading branch information
claude committed Oct 29, 2026
commit d095b1e16416d04f8d5fb093e9400a6636a3ed5e
Original file line number Diff line number Diff line change
@@ -1,6 +1,7 @@
{
"port": 4620,
"lead": "teammates.lead",
"lead": "teammates.chief-of-staff",
"leadName": "Chief of Staff",
"researcher": "teammates.researcher",
"ask": "Ask researcher for our launch date, and help me outline the post.",
"second": "Make section 2 about pricing.",
Expand Down
Original file line number Diff line number Diff line change
@@ -1,27 +1,27 @@
# teammates-lab › it a worker talks to another while you talk

**Issue:** FIX-2154 (leg b of the FIX-2152 epic's goal); step 5 and the held-out date amended by FIX-2309, step 5's coding task by FIX-2332, and its project by FIX-2335 (the lab has none); step 4 with FIX-1613
**Outcome:** In the Teammates lab, a list-of-workers app on the Grok Bot pattern, you talk to lead, lead messages researcher, and researcher's reply reaches lead while you are still talking to it; lead uses it. Long after both have left lead's history window, lead still knows them, and the screen shows where its word-for-word reading begins. A coding task lead starts runs in the background through Claude Code, in the user's one project, which lead puts its conversation in without asking.
**Input:** held out. The launch date is drawn at random each run and written into the working folder's README, which researcher reads and lead can't, so lead can only state it by hearing it from researcher. Step 4's codename (a colour, an animal and a number) is drawn per run, and its 60 lines are shuffled. The README's typo is one of several (`fixtures/input.json`). The lines you send are in the fixture.
**Outcome:** In the Teammates lab, a list-of-workers app on the Grok Bot pattern, you talk to Chief of Staff, Chief of Staff messages researcher, and researcher's reply reaches Chief of Staff while you are still talking to it; Chief of Staff uses it. Long after both have left Chief of Staff's history window, Chief of Staff still knows them, and the screen shows where its word-for-word reading begins. A coding task Chief of Staff starts runs in the background through Claude Code, in the user's one project, which Chief of Staff puts its conversation in without asking.
**Input:** held out. The launch date is drawn at random each run and written into the working folder's README, which researcher reads and Chief of Staff can't, so Chief of Staff can only state it by hearing it from researcher. Step 4's codename (a colour, an animal and a number) is drawn per run, and its 60 lines are shuffled. The README's typo is one of several (`fixtures/input.json`). The lines you send are in the fixture.
**Signal:**
- **1:** lead answers your first line in its conversation.
- **2:** a card *To researcher* in lead's conversation, a line *From lead* in researcher's, the exchange under *with researcher* in lead's Talk panel, and a delivered row lead → researcher in the message log.
- **3:** your second line goes in before researcher's reply has landed. The reply shows in lead's conversation under researcher's name, after lead's answer to you, carrying the date; the log holds it as a delivered reply; a line of lead's after it states the date.
- **4:** you tell lead a codename, then send 60 more lines, past the 50-turn history window, each answered before the next. Then you ask for the codename and the launch date. lead's answer holds all three words of the codename and the date, and lead sent researcher nothing new for it (no new card, no new log row). The conversation shows a divider labelled *Earlier turns summarized*, and both the codename line and researcher's reply are drawn above it.
- **5:** you ask for the fix. lead starts a coding task with no question: no card asks where, and no project shows anywhere on the page, nor in any worker's line. The coding task's run ends *done*, its steps show Claude Code, and the result lands in lead's conversation as the coding task's. On disk: the working folder's HEAD and working tree are untouched, and exactly one worktree of it, under the lab's runs folder, carries a commit that changes README.md alone, fixing its first line and nothing else.
**Anti-game:** Graded on what the browser shows, the message log read through the public client, and git. Never on the lab's adapter or the server's own state. Lead can't state the launch date without the reply, because it is drawn per run. The disk check reads git, so a run that only says it fixed the typo fails. The step-3 order check reads entry order as drawn, so a reply drawn before lead's answer fails. Step 4 counts lead's messages to researcher around the question, so asking researcher again for the date fails, and it reads which side of the divider each fact sits on, so a fact still read word for word doesn't count. Each graded list is floored with `tell.over`; an empty log or no worktree counts only where a control produces it, and says so.
**Model:** real — openai/gpt-5.4-mini (lead, researcher, writer); coder's run on Claude Code
- **1:** Chief of Staff answers your first line in its conversation.
- **2:** a card *To researcher* in Chief of Staff's conversation, a line *From Chief of Staff* in researcher's, the exchange under *with researcher* in Chief of Staff's Talk panel, and a delivered row Chief of Staff → researcher in the message log.
- **3:** your second line goes in before researcher's reply has landed. The reply shows in Chief of Staff's conversation under researcher's name, after Chief of Staff's answer to you, carrying the date; the log holds it as a delivered reply; a line of Chief of Staff's after it states the date.
- **4:** you tell Chief of Staff a codename, then send 60 more lines, past the 50-turn history window, each answered before the next. Then you ask for the codename and the launch date. Chief of Staff's answer holds all three words of the codename and the date, and Chief of Staff sent researcher nothing new for it (no new card, no new log row). The conversation shows a divider labelled *Earlier turns summarized*, and both the codename line and researcher's reply are drawn above it.
- **5:** you ask for the fix. Chief of Staff starts a coding task with no question: no card asks where, and no project shows anywhere on the page, nor in any worker's line. The coding task's run ends *done*, its steps show Claude Code, and the result lands in Chief of Staff's conversation as the coding task's. On disk: the working folder's HEAD and working tree are untouched, and exactly one worktree of it, under the lab's runs folder, carries a commit that changes README.md alone, fixing its first line and nothing else.
**Anti-game:** Graded on what the browser shows, the message log read through the public client, and git. Never on the lab's adapter or the server's own state. Chief of Staff can't state the launch date without the reply, because it is drawn per run. The disk check reads git, so a run that only says it fixed the typo fails. The step-3 order check reads entry order as drawn, so a reply drawn before Chief of Staff's answer fails. Step 4 counts Chief of Staff's messages to researcher around the question, so asking researcher again for the date fails, and it reads which side of the divider each fact sits on, so a fact still read word for word doesn't count. Each graded list is floored with `tell.over`; an empty log or no worktree counts only where a control produces it, and says so.
**Model:** real — openai/gpt-5.4-mini (Chief of Staff, researcher, writer); coder's run on Claude Code
**Run:** `pnpm tsx goals/teammates-lab/a-worker-talks-to-another-while-you-talk/run.mts` (needs `AI_GATEWAY_API_KEY`, and Claude Code signed in or `ANTHROPIC_API_KEY`)
**Controls:** each on the same command, failing the steps named and no other:
- `GOAL_CONTROL=no-model`: the workers answer on a model that doesn't exist. Steps 1, 2, 3 and 5 FAIL.
- `GOAL_CONTROL=no-lead-send`: lead's `sendMessage` is dropped from its tools (a scratch patch to `message-tool.ts`). Steps 2 and 3 FAIL. Step 5 may fail too: with no way to message, lead files its research ask as a task for coder, and after the pick it filed nothing again (2 of 2 runs).
- `GOAL_CONTROL=no-lead-send`: Chief of Staff's `sendMessage` is dropped from its tools (a scratch patch to `message-tool.ts`). Steps 2 and 3 FAIL. Step 5 may fail too: with no way to message, Chief of Staff files its research ask as a task for coder, and after the pick it filed nothing again (2 of 2 runs).
- `GOAL_CONTROL=no-reply-tool`: researcher's `sendMessage` is dropped. Step 3 FAILS.
- `GOAL_CONTROL=no-summary`: the history summary's capability and fold are dropped from the lab's host (a scratch patch to `host.mts`); memory stays. Step 4 FAILS: the divider can't say *summarized*.
- `GOAL_CONTROL=no-memory`: the summary and memory are both dropped from the host. Step 4 FAILS: nothing holds what left the window.

Step 4 is skipped under `no-model`, `no-lead-send` and `no-reply-tool`: its 60 lines test nothing about the step each control reddens.

Steps 2 and 3 have no isolating red state for lead's side: without lead's message there is nothing to reply to, so `no-lead-send` reddens both. Under `no-model` the screen doesn't show your own lines either until a reload: a turn that fails shows nothing live.
Steps 2 and 3 have no isolating red state for Chief of Staff's side: without Chief of Staff's message there is nothing to reply to, so `no-lead-send` reddens both. Under `no-model` the screen doesn't show your own lines either until a reload: a turn that fails shows nothing live.

## Verdict log
| Date | Commit | Model | Verdict | Notes |
Expand Down
Original file line number Diff line number Diff line change
Expand Up @@ -61,6 +61,8 @@ import { launchChromium } from "../../lib/playwright.mts";
interface Fixture {
port: number;
lead: string;
/** The name lead's `WORKER.md` declares, which the screen shows. */
leadName: string;
researcher: string;
ask: string;
second: string;
Expand Down Expand Up @@ -255,7 +257,8 @@ async function open(page: Page, worker: string): Promise<void> {

const userAt = (entries: Drawn[], text: string) => entries.findIndex((e) => e.kind === "user" && e.text.includes(text));
const lastUserAt = (entries: Drawn[], text: string) => entries.map((e) => e.kind === "user" && e.text.includes(text)).lastIndexOf(true);
const short = (id: string) => id.replace(/^teammates\./, "");
/** The name the screen shows for a worker: its declared name, else the last part of its id. */
const short = (id: string) => (id === fixture.lead ? fixture.leadName : id.replace(/^teammates\./, ""));

/** Say `text` to lead and wait until lead has answered it and finished the turn; false when it didn't in time. */
async function turnWith(page: Page, lead: string, text: string): Promise<boolean> {
Expand Down
Original file line number Diff line number Diff line change
@@ -1,5 +1,5 @@
{
"lead": "teammates.lead",
"lead": "teammates.chief-of-staff",
"writer": "teammates.writer",
"main": "desk.main",
"told": [
Expand Down
Original file line number Diff line number Diff line change
Expand Up @@ -8,13 +8,13 @@

**Signal:** `fsdev dev --app @flow-state-dev/teammates` on a copy of the lab's workers and a fresh store, and `fsdev dev --config labs/claude-code-style/fsdev.config.mts` on a fresh data folder, driven over HTTP.

- **Leg 1** (Teammates): the user says the line to `teammates.writer` in writer's conversation, then asks `teammates.lead` the question in lead's.
- *value named*: lead's reply contains the value.
- *reading names it*: a consult in that turn returned a reading that contains the value. The lab's memory (user-scoped episodic and semantic facts) also carries what writer heard to lead, so lead can name the value with no consult at all; the reply alone proves nothing here.
- **Leg 1** (Teammates): the user says the line to `teammates.writer` in writer's conversation, then asks `teammates.chief-of-staff` the question in Chief of Staff's.
- *value named*: Chief of Staff's reply contains the value.
- *reading names it*: a consult in that turn returned a reading that contains the value. The lab's memory (user-scoped episodic and semantic facts) also carries what writer heard to Chief of Staff, so Chief of Staff can name the value with no consult at all; the reply alone proves nothing here.
- *writer not woken*, *writer unchanged*: writer's conversation has the same number of requests and items as before the question.
- *no message*: the message log has no row.
- *utility model*: the consult's answer ran on `gpt-6-luna`, the lab's `models.intents.utility`, not lead's model. Its message is kept off the client, so this one is read from the lab's SQLite store.
- **Leg 2** (Teammates): a second user asks their own lead to read the first user's writer conversation by its id.
- *utility model*: the consult's answer ran on `gpt-6-luna`, the lab's `models.intents.utility`, not Chief of Staff's model. Its message is kept off the client, so this one is read from the lab's SQLite store.
- **Leg 2** (Teammates): a second user asks their own Chief of Staff to read the first user's writer conversation by its id.
- *no value*: neither the reply nor the consult result holds the value.
- *refused no_session*: the turn holds a consult refused `no_session`. A turn with no consult FAILS; it does not pass on the model declining.
- **Leg 3** (Claude Code-style): the user says the line in `desk.main` session A, then in session B asks what they said in session A, by its id.
Expand All @@ -23,15 +23,15 @@

Each leg passes in 3 runs of 3 (`GOAL_RUNS`, default 3).

**Anti-game:** Graded on the replies, the sessions' requests and items, the message log, and the store. The value is drawn per run. In the Teammates lab it reaches lead two ways, a consult and the lab's user memory, so leg 1 also needs a consult's reading that holds it and the consult's answer on the utility model. The Claude Code-style lab has no memory, so in leg 3 only a read of session A produces the value.
**Anti-game:** Graded on the replies, the sessions' requests and items, the message log, and the store. The value is drawn per run. In the Teammates lab it reaches Chief of Staff two ways, a consult and the lab's user memory, so leg 1 also needs a consult's reading that holds it and the consult's answer on the utility model. The Claude Code-style lab has no memory, so in leg 3 only a read of session A produces the value.

**Model:** real: `openai/gpt-5.4-mini` (Teammates), `openai/gpt-5.4` (Claude Code-style), consults on `openai/gpt-6-luna`.

**Run:** `pnpm tsx goals/teammates-lab/consults-a-conversation-without-waking-it/run.mts` (needs `AI_GATEWAY_API_KEY`; build both labs' pages first: `pnpm --filter @flow-state-dev/teammates build`, `pnpm --filter @flow-state-dev/claude-code-style build`).

**Controls:** each on the same command:

- `GOAL_CONTROL=no-consult`: lead's file (in the goal's copy of the tree) doesn't name `consultSessions: [consult]`. Leg 1 must FAIL on *reading names it* and *utility model*; *value named* can still pass, from memory. Leg 2 FAILS too (no consult call); leg 3 is not run.
- `GOAL_CONTROL=no-consult`: Chief of Staff's file (in the goal's copy of the tree) doesn't name `consultSessions: [consult]`. Leg 1 must FAIL on *reading names it* and *utility model*; *value named* can still pass, from memory. Leg 2 FAILS too (no consult call); leg 3 is not run.
- `GOAL_CONTROL=no-owner-check`: the engine's owner rule, shared by `sessions.read` and `sessions.history`, skips its user check as the server loads it (a scratch patch to `request-sessions.ts`). Leg 2 must FAIL on *no value*. Leg 3 is not run.

## Verdict log
Expand Down
Original file line number Diff line number Diff line change
Expand Up @@ -259,7 +259,7 @@ await runGoal(async (failures, tell) => {
const tree = join(goalTmpDir("consults-tree"), "workforce");
cpSync(join(LAB, "workforce"), tree, { recursive: true });
if (CONTROL === "no-consult") {
const file = join(tree, "teams/teammates/workers/lead/WORKER.md");
const file = join(tree, "teams/teammates/workers/chief-of-staff/WORKER.md");
const original = readFileSync(file, "utf8");
const stripped = original.replace(/\ncapabilities:\n consultSessions: \[consult\]\n/, "\n");
if (stripped === original) throw new Error("setup: lead's file names no consultSessions preset to drop");
Expand Down
Loading
Loading