Rename servicecatalogs phase1b #20
Conversation
…+ API) - Renamed Application layer: commands, queries, handlers, DTOs, ModuleApi - Renamed API layer: endpoints, extensions - Updated all namespaces and class references - Renamed ServiceCatalogsModuleApi and related files Files: 68 (Application + API layers) Phase: 1b of 3 Next: Phase 1c will add Tests layer
|
Warning Rate limit exceeded@frigini has exceeded the limit for the number of commits or files that can be reviewed per hour. Please wait 12 minutes and 22 seconds before requesting another review. ⌛ How to resolve this issue?After the wait time has elapsed, a review can be triggered using the We recommend that you space out your commits to avoid hitting the rate limit. 🚦 How do rate limits work?CodeRabbit enforces hourly rate limits for each developer per organization. Our paid plans have higher rate limits than the trial, open-source and free plans. In all cases, we re-allow further reviews after a brief timeout. Please see our FAQ for further information. 📒 Files selected for processing (5)
WalkthroughRenames the Catalogs solution entry to ServiceCatalogs and adds a new ServiceCatalogs module with API, Application projects, endpoints, CQRS commands/queries, handlers, DTOs, DI extensions, and a module API including EF migration handling and endpoint registration. Changes
Sequence Diagram(s)%%{init: {"theme":"base","themeVariables":{"primaryColor":"#E6F4EA","secondaryColor":"#F0F7FF","tertiaryColor":"#FFF9E6"}}}%%
sequenceDiagram
participant Client
participant API as ServiceCatalogs API Endpoint
participant Dispatcher as Command/Query Dispatcher
participant Handler as Command/Query Handler
participant Repo as Repository
participant DB as Database
Note over Client,API: HTTP request to module endpoint
Client->>API: POST/GET /... (with auth)
API->>API: validate auth & bind request
API->>Dispatcher: Dispatch Command/Query
Dispatcher->>Handler: Invoke HandleAsync
Handler->>Repo: Read/Write domain entities
Repo->>DB: Execute SQL/EF operations
DB-->>Repo: Result set / ack
Repo-->>Handler: Domain entity / counts
Handler->>Handler: Map to DTO / produce Result
Handler-->>Dispatcher: Result<T>
Dispatcher-->>API: Result<T>
API->>Client: HTTP response (200/201/204/404 + payload)
Estimated code review effort🎯 4 (Complex) | ⏱️ ~45 minutes Areas that may need extra attention:
Possibly related PRs
Poem
Pre-merge checks and finishing touches❌ Failed checks (1 warning)
✅ Passed checks (2 passed)
Thanks for using CodeRabbit! It's free for OSS, and your support helps us grow. If you like it, consider giving us a shout-out. Comment |
![coderabbitai[bot]](https://avatars.githubusercontent.com/in/347564?s=60&v=4){kind=small}
There was a problem hiding this comment.
Actionable comments posted: 5
🧹 Nitpick comments (25)
src/Modules/ServiceCatalogs/Application/Queries/ServiceCategory/GetServiceCategoriesWithCountQuery.cs (1)
7-8: Consider adding XML documentation for consistency.The
CreateServiceCommandfile includes XML documentation, but this query lacks it. Adding a summary would improve consistency and maintainability across the codebase.+/// <summary> +/// Query to retrieve service categories with service counts. +/// </summary> public sealed record GetServiceCategoriesWithCountQuery(bool ActiveOnly = false) : Query<Result<IReadOnlyList<ServiceCategoryWithCountDto>>>;src/Modules/ServiceCatalogs/Application/DTOs/Requests/Service/UpdateServiceRequest.cs (1)
5-10: Consider adding XML documentation.For consistency with other parts of the codebase (e.g.,
CreateServiceCommand), adding XML documentation would improve maintainability.src/Modules/ServiceCatalogs/Application/Queries/Service/GetServicesByCategoryQuery.cs (1)
7-8: Consider adding XML documentation for consistency.Similar to the suggestion for
GetServiceCategoriesWithCountQuery, adding XML documentation would align with theCreateServiceCommandpattern and improve maintainability.src/Modules/ServiceCatalogs/Application/Queries/ServiceCategory/GetServiceCategoryByIdQuery.cs (1)
7-8: Consider adding XML documentation for consistency.Adding XML documentation would align with patterns used elsewhere in the codebase (e.g.,
CreateServiceCommand).src/Modules/ServiceCatalogs/Application/Commands/ServiceCategory/UpdateServiceCategoryCommand.cs (1)
6-11: Consider adding XML documentation for consistency.The
CreateServiceCommandincludes XML documentation. Adding similar documentation here would improve consistency across the codebase.src/Modules/ServiceCatalogs/Application/Commands/ServiceCategory/ActivateServiceCategoryCommand.cs (1)
6-6: Consider adding XML documentation for consistency.Adding XML documentation would align with the pattern used in
CreateServiceCommandand improve code maintainability.src/Modules/ServiceCatalogs/API/Endpoints/ServiceCatalogsModuleEndpoints.cs (1)
20-20: Maintain existing URL paths for backward compatibility.The verification confirms that the old
/api/v1/catalogs/categoriesand/api/v1/catalogs/servicespaths are extensively used in integration tests and documented in multiple documentation files (roadmap.md and catalogs.md). This indicates the paths are intentionally maintained as established API contracts. Changing them would constitute a breaking change. The module rename from Catalogs to ServiceCatalogs is an internal organizational change; the API paths should remain stable for backward compatibility with existing clients.src/Modules/ServiceCatalogs/API/Endpoints/ServiceCategory/GetAllServiceCategoriesEndpoint.cs (1)
14-14: Consider consistency with other endpoints.The API query record
GetAllCategoriesQuerydefined here differs from the pattern inGetAllServicesEndpoint, which usesGetAllServicesQuerydirectly with[AsParameters]. Consider using the application query directly for consistency, or establish a clear naming convention if API-level query models are preferred.src/Modules/ServiceCatalogs/API/Endpoints/ServiceCategory/ActivateServiceCategoryEndpoint.cs (1)
14-29: Activation endpoint wiring looks correct; consider documenting error responsesThe route, authorization, command dispatch, and
HandleNoContentusage are consistent with the deactivation endpoint and look good. As a small improvement, you might add.Producesfor typical error cases (e.g., validation/authorization failures) so they appear explicitly in the OpenAPI description, mirroring how success is documented.src/Modules/ServiceCatalogs/API/Endpoints/Service/CreateServiceEndpoint.cs (1)
18-37: Create endpoint mirrors existing pattern and is wired correctlyThe POST mapping, admin requirement, command creation, and
Createdresponse viaHandle(result, "GetServiceById", …)all look correct and consistent with the previous Catalogs implementation. Theresult.Value!usage is acceptable assuming the handler guarantees a non-null DTO on success.src/Modules/ServiceCatalogs/Application/Handlers/Commands/Service/DeleteServiceCommandHandler.cs (1)
13-34: Delete handler flow is solid; consider more explicit not-found semanticsThe input validation, repository lookup, and deletion flow look good, and the TODO notes for provider checks/soft-delete are helpful. If your
Result/EndpointExtensionsstack differentiates between validation errors and not-found cases, you might want to use a more specific error (e.g., a typedError.NotFoundor similar) instead of a plain string for the "service not found" branch so the HTTP layer can reliably emit a 404 instead of a generic 400.src/Modules/ServiceCatalogs/API/Endpoints/ServiceCategory/GetServiceCategoryByIdEndpoint.cs (1)
15-35: Category GET endpoint matches the established query patternThe endpoint mapping, query dispatch, null → 404 handling, and delegation to
Handle(result)are all consistent with the service GET endpoint and the shared base endpoint utilities. Only nit is style (== nullvsis null), but functionally this is fine.src/Modules/ServiceCatalogs/API/Extensions.cs (1)
41-85: Make migration preconditions and skips visible in logsCurrent logic quietly returns when the
ServiceCatalogsDbContextorILoggercan’t be resolved, and also when running under"Test"/"Testing"environments. That can make misconfiguration or unintended environment settings hard to spot.Consider:
- Logging at least a warning when
ServiceCatalogsDbContextis not found before returning (Line 49).- Logging that migrations are being skipped in test environments (Lines 51–55).
This keeps the startup behavior transparent without changing control flow.
src/Modules/ServiceCatalogs/Application/Handlers/Queries/ServiceCategory/GetServiceCategoriesWithCountQueryHandler.cs (1)
18-48: Correct aggregation; consider repository-level optimization if this endpoint growsThe handler correctly builds
ServiceCategoryWithCountDtoobjects and already documents the 2×N count query pattern. For now this is fine, but if categories grow large or this endpoint becomes hot:
- Consider adding a repository method that returns counts for all categories in a single grouped query instead of per‑category calls.
- Optionally pre‑allocate the list with
new List<ServiceCategoryWithCountDto>(categories.Count)to avoid reallocation.These are forward‑looking, not blockers.
src/Modules/ServiceCatalogs/Application/Handlers/Queries/Service/GetServiceByIdQueryHandler.cs (1)
18-42: AlignGuid.Emptyhandling with the rest of the moduleHere,
Guid.Emptyand “service not found” both result inResult<ServiceDto?>.Success(null), which the endpoint then maps to 404. In other handlers (e.g.,DeactivateServiceCategoryCommandHandler),Guid.Emptyis treated as a validation error and returns a failure with a message.To keep the API behavior consistent:
- Either treat
Guid.Emptyas invalid input here as well (e.g., return a failure with a validation message), or- Explicitly document that for queries
Guid.Emptyis normalized to “not found” while commands treat it as invalid.The current implementation is functionally fine, but aligning semantics will make consumer expectations clearer.
src/Modules/ServiceCatalogs/Application/Handlers/Commands/ServiceCategory/CreateServiceCategoryCommandHandler.cs (1)
19-47: Creation flow looks good; confirm uniqueness enforcement under concurrencyThe handler does the right things: trims and validates the name, checks for duplicates, creates the domain entity, and maps it to a DTO while catching
CatalogDomainException. One nuance:
ExistsWithNameAsync(normalizedName, null, ...)followed byAddAsynccan still allow a race where two concurrent requests create the same name unless there’s a unique constraint at the DB level (or the repository translates a unique‑violation into a domain/persistence exception).If not already in place, consider:
- Enforcing a unique index/constraint on the category name.
- Mapping any unique‑constraint violation from
AddAsyncinto a domain‑level conflict error consistent with the duplicate‑name message.Otherwise, the handler itself looks solid.
src/Modules/ServiceCatalogs/API/Endpoints/ServiceCategory/CreateServiceCategoryEndpoint.cs (1)
26-39: Consider safer null handling for the success case.Line 38 uses the null-forgiving operator (
result.Value!.Id), which assumes thatValueis never null whenIsSuccessis true. While the guard on line 35-36 makes this safe in practice, it's slightly brittle.Consider this more defensive approach:
if (!result.IsSuccess) return Handle(result); - return Handle(result, "GetServiceCategoryById", new { id = result.Value!.Id }); + return Handle(result, "GetServiceCategoryById", new { id = result.Value?.Id ?? Guid.Empty });Or even better, assert the contract explicitly:
if (!result.IsSuccess) return Handle(result); + + if (result.Value is null) + return BadRequest("Unexpected null value in successful result."); return Handle(result, "GetServiceCategoryById", new { id = result.Value.Id });src/Modules/ServiceCatalogs/Application/Handlers/Queries/Service/GetAllServicesQueryHandler.cs (1)
18-24: Consider extracting DTO mapping for consistency.The mapping from
ServicetoServiceListDto(lines 18-24) is duplicated inGetServicesByCategoryQueryHandler(lines 23-29). While this is acceptable, extracting to an extension method or mapper could improve maintainability.For example, create an extension method in a
ServiceMappingExtensionsclass:public static class ServiceMappingExtensions { public static ServiceListDto ToListDto(this Domain.Entities.Service service) => new( service.Id.Value, service.CategoryId.Value, service.Name, service.Description, service.IsActive); }Then simplify the handlers:
var dtos = services.Select(s => s.ToListDto()).ToList();src/Modules/ServiceCatalogs/Application/Handlers/Queries/ServiceCategory/GetAllServiceCategoriesQueryHandler.cs (1)
18-26: Consider extracting DTO mapping for consistency.Similar to the service handlers, the category-to-DTO mapping is duplicated in
GetServiceCategoryByIdQueryHandler(lines 26-34). Extracting to an extension method would improve consistency.Example:
public static class ServiceCategoryMappingExtensions { public static ServiceCategoryDto ToDto(this Domain.Entities.ServiceCategory category) => new( category.Id.Value, category.Name, category.Description, category.IsActive, category.DisplayOrder, category.CreatedAt, category.UpdatedAt); }Then use:
var dtos = categories.Select(c => c.ToDto()).ToList();src/Modules/ServiceCatalogs/Application/ModuleApi/ServiceCatalogsModuleApi.cs (6)
21-57: Module metadata and availability check are solid; consider refining cancellation handlingThe
ModuleMetadatastatic class andModuleName/ApiVersionproperties are straightforward and suitable for the[ModuleApi]attribute.IsAvailableAsyncdoes a cheap, representative DB call and logs appropriately; behavior on generic exceptions is good.One small refinement: for consistency with other methods, you might either:
- Also catch
OperationCanceledExceptionseparately here and rethrow (as you already do), and optionally apply the same pattern to the other methods; or- Let
OperationCanceledExceptionbubble everywhere by not catching it in a genericcatchat all.Right now only this method treats cancellation specially while others report it as an error, which may be slightly inconsistent from a caller’s perspective.
59-89: GetServiceCategoryByIdAsync: behavior and mapping look goodInput validation, value-object conversion, repository call, and mapping to
ModuleServiceCategoryDtoare all clear and side-effect free. ReturningSuccess(null)for not-found is consistent with a query-style API.If you plan to localize or centralize messages, you could later replace the hard-coded
"Category id must be provided"and"Error retrieving service category: ..."strings with entries inValidationMessagesor a similar resource, but it’s fine as-is for internal module APIs.
116-149: GetServiceByIdAsync: null-handling and “unknown category” default are sensibleValidation, VO creation and repository call are standard and correct. You’re defensively handling a missing
Categorynavigation viaservice.Category?.Name ?? ValidationMessages.Catalogs.UnknownCategoryName, while still usingservice.CategoryId.Valueas the key, which is reasonable given the domain likely guarantees a non-nullCategoryId.Same optional note as before: if error messages will be surfaced to end users or logs in localized environments, consider centralizing
"Service id must be provided"/"Error retrieving service: ..."later.
175-205: GetServicesByCategoryAsync: good validation; duplication with other mappers is acceptableInput validation on
categoryId, VO conversion, and batch fetch by category are all correct. The mapping toModuleServiceDtomirrorsGetServiceByIdAsyncand keeps behavior consistent (including the unknown category name fallback).There is some duplication in DTO construction across methods, but given the small mapping surface, extracting a shared private mapper is optional, not required.
206-229: IsServiceActiveAsync: clear semantics for not-found vs inactiveThe method clearly distinguishes:
- invalid id →
Failure, and- not-found service →
Success(false),which matches the comment about query semantics. Logging and wrapping in
Result<bool>look correct. Just ensure callers understand thatfalsecan mean both “does not exist” and “inactive”; if that ever becomes ambiguous, you might later expose a richer status type.
231-303: ValidateServicesAsync: good dedup + batch-strategy; minor polish possibleThe validation logic is well thought out:
- Null check and empty-collection short-circuit are defensive and efficient.
Distinct()on input followed by separation ofGuid.EmptyintoinvalidIdsprevents redundant DB work.- Batched
GetByIdsAsyncandToDictionaryavoid N+1 queries and give O(n) membership checks.- Output
ModuleServiceValidationResultDtowithAllValid,InvalidServiceIds, andInactiveServiceIdsis clean and easy to consume.A couple of minor polish ideas (optional):
- You could treat
serviceIdsasIEnumerable<Guid>instead ofIReadOnlyCollection<Guid>to allow streaming callers and only materialize once, but the current type is fine for most usages.- If you ever need to preserve ordering from the input, you’d need to adjust the
Distinct()+ lookup logic; right now the result lists are essentially set-based, which is perfectly acceptable for validation semantics.No correctness issues spotted here.
📜 Review details
Configuration used: CodeRabbit UI
Review profile: CHILL
Plan: Pro
📒 Files selected for processing (68)
MeAjudaAi.sln(3 hunks)src/Modules/ServiceCatalogs/API/Endpoints/Service/ActivateServiceEndpoint.cs(1 hunks)src/Modules/ServiceCatalogs/API/Endpoints/Service/ChangeServiceCategoryEndpoint.cs(1 hunks)src/Modules/ServiceCatalogs/API/Endpoints/Service/CreateServiceEndpoint.cs(1 hunks)src/Modules/ServiceCatalogs/API/Endpoints/Service/DeactivateServiceEndpoint.cs(1 hunks)src/Modules/ServiceCatalogs/API/Endpoints/Service/DeleteServiceEndpoint.cs(1 hunks)src/Modules/ServiceCatalogs/API/Endpoints/Service/GetAllServicesEndpoint.cs(1 hunks)src/Modules/ServiceCatalogs/API/Endpoints/Service/GetServiceByIdEndpoint.cs(1 hunks)src/Modules/ServiceCatalogs/API/Endpoints/Service/GetServicesByCategoryEndpoint.cs(1 hunks)src/Modules/ServiceCatalogs/API/Endpoints/Service/UpdateServiceEndpoint.cs(1 hunks)src/Modules/ServiceCatalogs/API/Endpoints/Service/ValidateServicesEndpoint.cs(1 hunks)src/Modules/ServiceCatalogs/API/Endpoints/ServiceCatalogsModuleEndpoints.cs(1 hunks)src/Modules/ServiceCatalogs/API/Endpoints/ServiceCategory/ActivateServiceCategoryEndpoint.cs(1 hunks)src/Modules/ServiceCatalogs/API/Endpoints/ServiceCategory/CreateServiceCategoryEndpoint.cs(1 hunks)src/Modules/ServiceCatalogs/API/Endpoints/ServiceCategory/DeactivateServiceCategoryEndpoint.cs(1 hunks)src/Modules/ServiceCatalogs/API/Endpoints/ServiceCategory/DeleteServiceCategoryEndpoint.cs(1 hunks)src/Modules/ServiceCatalogs/API/Endpoints/ServiceCategory/GetAllServiceCategoriesEndpoint.cs(1 hunks)src/Modules/ServiceCatalogs/API/Endpoints/ServiceCategory/GetServiceCategoryByIdEndpoint.cs(1 hunks)src/Modules/ServiceCatalogs/API/Endpoints/ServiceCategory/UpdateServiceCategoryEndpoint.cs(1 hunks)src/Modules/ServiceCatalogs/API/Extensions.cs(1 hunks)src/Modules/ServiceCatalogs/API/MeAjudaAi.Modules.ServiceCatalogs.API.csproj(1 hunks)src/Modules/ServiceCatalogs/Application/Commands/Service/ActivateServiceCommand.cs(1 hunks)src/Modules/ServiceCatalogs/Application/Commands/Service/ChangeServiceCategoryCommand.cs(1 hunks)src/Modules/ServiceCatalogs/Application/Commands/Service/CreateServiceCommand.cs(1 hunks)src/Modules/ServiceCatalogs/Application/Commands/Service/DeactivateServiceCommand.cs(1 hunks)src/Modules/ServiceCatalogs/Application/Commands/Service/DeleteServiceCommand.cs(1 hunks)src/Modules/ServiceCatalogs/Application/Commands/Service/UpdateServiceCommand.cs(1 hunks)src/Modules/ServiceCatalogs/Application/Commands/ServiceCategory/ActivateServiceCategoryCommand.cs(1 hunks)src/Modules/ServiceCatalogs/Application/Commands/ServiceCategory/CreateServiceCategoryCommand.cs(1 hunks)src/Modules/ServiceCatalogs/Application/Commands/ServiceCategory/DeactivateServiceCategoryCommand.cs(1 hunks)src/Modules/ServiceCatalogs/Application/Commands/ServiceCategory/DeleteServiceCategoryCommand.cs(1 hunks)src/Modules/ServiceCatalogs/Application/Commands/ServiceCategory/UpdateServiceCategoryCommand.cs(1 hunks)src/Modules/ServiceCatalogs/Application/DTOs/Requests/Service/ChangeServiceCategoryRequest.cs(1 hunks)src/Modules/ServiceCatalogs/Application/DTOs/Requests/Service/CreateServiceRequest.cs(1 hunks)src/Modules/ServiceCatalogs/Application/DTOs/Requests/Service/UpdateServiceRequest.cs(1 hunks)src/Modules/ServiceCatalogs/Application/DTOs/Requests/Service/ValidateServicesRequest.cs(1 hunks)src/Modules/ServiceCatalogs/Application/DTOs/Requests/Service/ValidateServicesResponse.cs(1 hunks)src/Modules/ServiceCatalogs/Application/DTOs/Requests/ServiceCategory/UpdateServiceCategoryRequest.cs(1 hunks)src/Modules/ServiceCatalogs/Application/DTOs/ServiceCategoryDto.cs(1 hunks)src/Modules/ServiceCatalogs/Application/DTOs/ServiceCategoryWithCountDto.cs(1 hunks)src/Modules/ServiceCatalogs/Application/DTOs/ServiceDto.cs(1 hunks)src/Modules/ServiceCatalogs/Application/DTOs/ServiceListDto.cs(1 hunks)src/Modules/ServiceCatalogs/Application/Extensions.cs(1 hunks)src/Modules/ServiceCatalogs/Application/Handlers/Commands/Service/ActivateServiceCommandHandler.cs(1 hunks)src/Modules/ServiceCatalogs/Application/Handlers/Commands/Service/ChangeServiceCategoryCommandHandler.cs(1 hunks)src/Modules/ServiceCatalogs/Application/Handlers/Commands/Service/CreateServiceCommandHandler.cs(1 hunks)src/Modules/ServiceCatalogs/Application/Handlers/Commands/Service/DeactivateServiceCommandHandler.cs(1 hunks)src/Modules/ServiceCatalogs/Application/Handlers/Commands/Service/DeleteServiceCommandHandler.cs(1 hunks)src/Modules/ServiceCatalogs/Application/Handlers/Commands/Service/UpdateServiceCommandHandler.cs(1 hunks)src/Modules/ServiceCatalogs/Application/Handlers/Commands/ServiceCategory/ActivateServiceCategoryCommandHandler.cs(1 hunks)src/Modules/ServiceCatalogs/Application/Handlers/Commands/ServiceCategory/CreateServiceCategoryCommandHandler.cs(1 hunks)src/Modules/ServiceCatalogs/Application/Handlers/Commands/ServiceCategory/DeactivateServiceCategoryCommandHandler.cs(1 hunks)src/Modules/ServiceCatalogs/Application/Handlers/Commands/ServiceCategory/DeleteServiceCategoryCommandHandler.cs(1 hunks)src/Modules/ServiceCatalogs/Application/Handlers/Commands/ServiceCategory/UpdateServiceCategoryCommandHandler.cs(1 hunks)src/Modules/ServiceCatalogs/Application/Handlers/Queries/Service/GetAllServicesQueryHandler.cs(1 hunks)src/Modules/ServiceCatalogs/Application/Handlers/Queries/Service/GetServiceByIdQueryHandler.cs(1 hunks)src/Modules/ServiceCatalogs/Application/Handlers/Queries/Service/GetServicesByCategoryQueryHandler.cs(1 hunks)src/Modules/ServiceCatalogs/Application/Handlers/Queries/ServiceCategory/GetAllServiceCategoriesQueryHandler.cs(1 hunks)src/Modules/ServiceCatalogs/Application/Handlers/Queries/ServiceCategory/GetServiceCategoriesWithCountQueryHandler.cs(1 hunks)src/Modules/ServiceCatalogs/Application/Handlers/Queries/ServiceCategory/GetServiceCategoryByIdQueryHandler.cs(1 hunks)src/Modules/ServiceCatalogs/Application/MeAjudaAi.Modules.ServiceCatalogs.Application.csproj(1 hunks)src/Modules/ServiceCatalogs/Application/ModuleApi/ServiceCatalogsModuleApi.cs(1 hunks)src/Modules/ServiceCatalogs/Application/Queries/Service/GetAllServicesQuery.cs(1 hunks)src/Modules/ServiceCatalogs/Application/Queries/Service/GetServiceByIdQuery.cs(1 hunks)src/Modules/ServiceCatalogs/Application/Queries/Service/GetServicesByCategoryQuery.cs(1 hunks)src/Modules/ServiceCatalogs/Application/Queries/ServiceCategory/GetAllServiceCategoriesQuery.cs(1 hunks)src/Modules/ServiceCatalogs/Application/Queries/ServiceCategory/GetServiceCategoriesWithCountQuery.cs(1 hunks)src/Modules/ServiceCatalogs/Application/Queries/ServiceCategory/GetServiceCategoryByIdQuery.cs(1 hunks)
🧰 Additional context used
🧬 Code graph analysis (43)
src/Modules/ServiceCatalogs/Application/Commands/Service/ChangeServiceCategoryCommand.cs (1)
src/Modules/Users/Infrastructure/Services/MockAuthenticationDomainService.cs (1)
Guid(86-96)
src/Modules/ServiceCatalogs/API/Endpoints/Service/GetServicesByCategoryEndpoint.cs (3)
src/Shared/Endpoints/BaseEndpoint.cs (1)
BaseEndpoint(10-130)src/Modules/ServiceCatalogs/API/Endpoints/Service/GetAllServicesEndpoint.cs (2)
Map(16-20)Task(22-30)src/Modules/ServiceCatalogs/API/Endpoints/Service/GetServiceByIdEndpoint.cs (2)
Map(15-20)Task(22-36)
src/Modules/ServiceCatalogs/API/Endpoints/Service/DeleteServiceEndpoint.cs (1)
src/Shared/Endpoints/BaseEndpoint.cs (1)
BaseEndpoint(10-130)
src/Modules/ServiceCatalogs/Application/DTOs/ServiceListDto.cs (1)
src/Modules/Catalogs/Application/DTOs/ServiceListDto.cs (1)
ServiceListDto(6-12)
src/Modules/ServiceCatalogs/Application/DTOs/Requests/Service/ChangeServiceCategoryRequest.cs (1)
src/Modules/Catalogs/Application/DTOs/Requests.cs (1)
ChangeServiceCategoryRequest(35-38)
src/Modules/ServiceCatalogs/API/Endpoints/ServiceCategory/DeleteServiceCategoryEndpoint.cs (2)
src/Shared/Endpoints/BaseEndpoint.cs (1)
BaseEndpoint(10-130)src/Modules/ServiceCatalogs/API/Endpoints/Service/DeleteServiceEndpoint.cs (2)
Map(14-19)Task(21-29)
src/Modules/ServiceCatalogs/API/Endpoints/Service/ActivateServiceEndpoint.cs (3)
src/Shared/Endpoints/BaseEndpoint.cs (1)
BaseEndpoint(10-130)src/Modules/ServiceCatalogs/API/Endpoints/Service/ChangeServiceCategoryEndpoint.cs (2)
Map(16-21)Task(23-32)src/Modules/ServiceCatalogs/API/Endpoints/Service/DeactivateServiceEndpoint.cs (2)
Map(14-19)Task(21-29)
src/Modules/ServiceCatalogs/Application/Extensions.cs (2)
src/Modules/ServiceCatalogs/Application/ModuleApi/ServiceCatalogsModuleApi.cs (1)
ModuleApi(20-304)src/Modules/Catalogs/Application/Extensions.cs (1)
Extensions(7-20)
src/Modules/ServiceCatalogs/Application/Commands/Service/CreateServiceCommand.cs (1)
src/Modules/Catalogs/Application/Commands/Service/CreateServiceCommand.cs (1)
CreateServiceCommand(10-15)
src/Modules/ServiceCatalogs/Application/Handlers/Commands/Service/DeactivateServiceCommandHandler.cs (1)
src/Modules/ServiceCatalogs/API/Endpoints/Service/DeactivateServiceEndpoint.cs (1)
Task(21-29)
src/Modules/ServiceCatalogs/API/Endpoints/Service/GetAllServicesEndpoint.cs (4)
src/Shared/Endpoints/BaseEndpoint.cs (1)
BaseEndpoint(10-130)src/Modules/ServiceCatalogs/API/Endpoints/Service/GetServicesByCategoryEndpoint.cs (2)
Map(16-20)Task(22-31)src/Modules/ServiceCatalogs/API/Endpoints/ServiceCategory/GetAllServiceCategoriesEndpoint.cs (2)
Map(18-22)Task(24-34)src/Shared/Contracts/Response.cs (1)
Response(12-20)
src/Modules/ServiceCatalogs/Application/Handlers/Commands/Service/DeleteServiceCommandHandler.cs (1)
src/Modules/ServiceCatalogs/API/Endpoints/Service/DeleteServiceEndpoint.cs (1)
Task(21-29)
src/Modules/ServiceCatalogs/Application/Handlers/Commands/Service/ActivateServiceCommandHandler.cs (2)
src/Modules/ServiceCatalogs/API/Endpoints/Service/ActivateServiceEndpoint.cs (1)
Task(21-29)src/Modules/Catalogs/Application/Handlers/Commands/CommandHandlers.cs (1)
ActivateServiceCommandHandler(274-295)
src/Modules/ServiceCatalogs/API/Endpoints/Service/UpdateServiceEndpoint.cs (2)
src/Shared/Endpoints/BaseEndpoint.cs (1)
BaseEndpoint(10-130)src/Modules/Catalogs/API/Endpoints/ServiceEndpoints.cs (1)
UpdateServiceEndpoint(120-139)
src/Modules/ServiceCatalogs/API/Endpoints/ServiceCategory/CreateServiceCategoryEndpoint.cs (3)
src/Shared/Endpoints/BaseEndpoint.cs (1)
BaseEndpoint(10-130)src/Modules/ServiceCatalogs/API/Endpoints/ServiceCategory/GetServiceCategoryByIdEndpoint.cs (2)
Map(15-20)Task(22-35)src/Shared/Contracts/Response.cs (1)
Response(12-20)
src/Modules/ServiceCatalogs/API/Endpoints/ServiceCategory/ActivateServiceCategoryEndpoint.cs (2)
src/Shared/Endpoints/BaseEndpoint.cs (1)
BaseEndpoint(10-130)src/Modules/ServiceCatalogs/API/Endpoints/ServiceCategory/DeactivateServiceCategoryEndpoint.cs (2)
Map(14-19)Task(21-29)
src/Modules/ServiceCatalogs/Application/Handlers/Commands/ServiceCategory/CreateServiceCategoryCommandHandler.cs (2)
src/Modules/ServiceCatalogs/API/Endpoints/ServiceCategory/CreateServiceCategoryEndpoint.cs (1)
Task(26-39)src/Modules/Catalogs/Application/Handlers/Commands/CommandHandlers.cs (1)
CreateServiceCategoryCommandHandler(17-50)
src/Modules/ServiceCatalogs/API/Endpoints/ServiceCategory/UpdateServiceCategoryEndpoint.cs (3)
src/Shared/Endpoints/BaseEndpoint.cs (1)
BaseEndpoint(10-130)src/Modules/ServiceCatalogs/API/Endpoints/Service/UpdateServiceEndpoint.cs (2)
Map(16-21)Task(23-32)src/Modules/ServiceCatalogs/API/Endpoints/ServiceCategory/CreateServiceCategoryEndpoint.cs (2)
Map(19-24)Task(26-39)
src/Modules/ServiceCatalogs/Application/Handlers/Queries/ServiceCategory/GetServiceCategoryByIdQueryHandler.cs (1)
src/Modules/ServiceCatalogs/API/Endpoints/ServiceCategory/GetServiceCategoryByIdEndpoint.cs (1)
Task(22-35)
src/Modules/ServiceCatalogs/API/Endpoints/ServiceCatalogsModuleEndpoints.cs (3)
src/Modules/ServiceCatalogs/API/Extensions.cs (1)
WebApplication(31-39)src/Shared/Endpoints/BaseEndpoint.cs (1)
BaseEndpoint(10-130)src/Modules/Catalogs/API/Endpoints/CatalogsModuleEndpoints.cs (1)
CatalogsModuleEndpoints(9-42)
src/Modules/ServiceCatalogs/Application/Handlers/Commands/ServiceCategory/UpdateServiceCategoryCommandHandler.cs (1)
src/Modules/Catalogs/Application/Handlers/Commands/CommandHandlers.cs (1)
UpdateServiceCategoryCommandHandler(51-83)
src/Modules/ServiceCatalogs/API/Extensions.cs (2)
src/Modules/ServiceCatalogs/Application/Extensions.cs (2)
Extensions(7-20)IServiceCollection(9-19)src/Modules/ServiceCatalogs/API/Endpoints/ServiceCatalogsModuleEndpoints.cs (1)
MapServiceCatalogsEndpoints(17-43)
src/Modules/ServiceCatalogs/Application/Handlers/Queries/Service/GetAllServicesQueryHandler.cs (2)
src/Modules/ServiceCatalogs/API/Endpoints/Service/GetAllServicesEndpoint.cs (1)
Task(22-30)src/Modules/Catalogs/Application/Handlers/Queries/QueryHandlers.cs (1)
GetAllServicesQueryHandler(47-66)
src/Modules/ServiceCatalogs/Application/Handlers/Commands/ServiceCategory/DeactivateServiceCategoryCommandHandler.cs (1)
src/Modules/ServiceCatalogs/API/Endpoints/ServiceCategory/DeactivateServiceCategoryEndpoint.cs (1)
Task(21-29)
src/Modules/ServiceCatalogs/Application/Handlers/Commands/Service/ChangeServiceCategoryCommandHandler.cs (2)
src/Modules/ServiceCatalogs/API/Endpoints/Service/ChangeServiceCategoryEndpoint.cs (1)
Task(23-32)src/Modules/Catalogs/Application/Handlers/Commands/CommandHandlers.cs (2)
ChangeServiceCategoryCommandHandler(320-372)Task(325-371)
src/Modules/ServiceCatalogs/API/Endpoints/Service/DeactivateServiceEndpoint.cs (2)
src/Shared/Endpoints/BaseEndpoint.cs (1)
BaseEndpoint(10-130)src/Modules/Catalogs/API/Endpoints/ServiceEndpoints.cs (1)
DeactivateServiceEndpoint(210-228)
src/Modules/ServiceCatalogs/API/Endpoints/ServiceCategory/GetAllServiceCategoriesEndpoint.cs (3)
src/Shared/Endpoints/BaseEndpoint.cs (1)
BaseEndpoint(10-130)src/Modules/ServiceCatalogs/API/Endpoints/Service/GetAllServicesEndpoint.cs (2)
Map(16-20)Task(22-30)src/Shared/Contracts/Response.cs (1)
Response(12-20)
src/Modules/ServiceCatalogs/Application/Handlers/Queries/Service/GetServiceByIdQueryHandler.cs (2)
src/Modules/ServiceCatalogs/API/Endpoints/Service/GetServiceByIdEndpoint.cs (1)
Task(22-36)src/Shared/Constants/ValidationMessages.cs (2)
ValidationMessages(9-90)Catalogs(83-89)
src/Modules/ServiceCatalogs/API/Endpoints/Service/CreateServiceEndpoint.cs (3)
src/Shared/Endpoints/BaseEndpoint.cs (1)
BaseEndpoint(10-130)src/Modules/ServiceCatalogs/API/Endpoints/Service/GetServiceByIdEndpoint.cs (2)
Map(15-20)Task(22-36)src/Modules/Catalogs/API/Endpoints/ServiceEndpoints.cs (1)
CreateServiceEndpoint(23-45)
src/Modules/ServiceCatalogs/Application/Commands/ServiceCategory/DeactivateServiceCategoryCommand.cs (1)
src/Modules/Catalogs/Application/Commands/ServiceCategory/DeactivateServiceCategoryCommand.cs (1)
DeactivateServiceCategoryCommand(6-6)
src/Modules/ServiceCatalogs/Application/ModuleApi/ServiceCatalogsModuleApi.cs (3)
src/Modules/ServiceCatalogs/Application/Extensions.cs (1)
Extensions(7-20)src/Modules/ServiceCatalogs/API/Endpoints/Service/ValidateServicesEndpoint.cs (1)
Task(23-41)src/Shared/Constants/ValidationMessages.cs (2)
ValidationMessages(9-90)Catalogs(83-89)
src/Modules/ServiceCatalogs/Application/Handlers/Commands/ServiceCategory/ActivateServiceCategoryCommandHandler.cs (2)
src/Modules/ServiceCatalogs/API/Endpoints/ServiceCategory/ActivateServiceCategoryEndpoint.cs (1)
Task(21-29)src/Modules/Catalogs/Application/Handlers/Commands/CommandHandlers.cs (1)
ActivateServiceCategoryCommandHandler(112-133)
src/Modules/ServiceCatalogs/Application/Handlers/Queries/Service/GetServicesByCategoryQueryHandler.cs (2)
src/Modules/ServiceCatalogs/API/Endpoints/Service/GetServicesByCategoryEndpoint.cs (1)
Task(22-31)src/Modules/Catalogs/Application/Handlers/Queries/QueryHandlers.cs (1)
GetServicesByCategoryQueryHandler(68-88)
src/Modules/ServiceCatalogs/Application/Handlers/Queries/ServiceCategory/GetAllServiceCategoriesQueryHandler.cs (1)
src/Modules/ServiceCatalogs/API/Endpoints/ServiceCategory/GetAllServiceCategoriesEndpoint.cs (1)
Task(24-34)
src/Modules/ServiceCatalogs/Application/Handlers/Commands/Service/UpdateServiceCommandHandler.cs (2)
src/Modules/ServiceCatalogs/API/Endpoints/Service/UpdateServiceEndpoint.cs (1)
Task(23-32)src/Modules/Catalogs/Application/Handlers/Commands/CommandHandlers.cs (1)
UpdateServiceCommandHandler(212-244)
src/Modules/ServiceCatalogs/API/Endpoints/ServiceCategory/GetServiceCategoryByIdEndpoint.cs (3)
src/Shared/Endpoints/BaseEndpoint.cs (1)
BaseEndpoint(10-130)src/Modules/ServiceCatalogs/API/Endpoints/Service/GetServiceByIdEndpoint.cs (2)
Map(15-20)Task(22-36)src/Modules/ServiceCatalogs/API/Endpoints/ServiceCategory/CreateServiceCategoryEndpoint.cs (2)
Map(19-24)Task(26-39)
src/Modules/ServiceCatalogs/Application/Handlers/Commands/Service/CreateServiceCommandHandler.cs (2)
src/Modules/ServiceCatalogs/API/Endpoints/Service/CreateServiceEndpoint.cs (1)
Task(25-37)src/Modules/Catalogs/Application/Handlers/Commands/CommandHandlers.cs (1)
CreateServiceCommandHandler(162-210)
src/Modules/ServiceCatalogs/Application/Handlers/Commands/ServiceCategory/DeleteServiceCategoryCommandHandler.cs (2)
src/Modules/ServiceCatalogs/API/Endpoints/ServiceCategory/DeleteServiceCategoryEndpoint.cs (1)
Task(21-29)src/Modules/Catalogs/Application/Handlers/Commands/CommandHandlers.cs (1)
DeleteServiceCategoryCommandHandler(85-110)
src/Modules/ServiceCatalogs/API/Endpoints/Service/ChangeServiceCategoryEndpoint.cs (2)
src/Shared/Endpoints/BaseEndpoint.cs (1)
BaseEndpoint(10-130)src/Modules/Catalogs/API/Endpoints/ServiceEndpoints.cs (1)
ChangeServiceCategoryEndpoint(141-160)
src/Modules/ServiceCatalogs/Application/Commands/Service/UpdateServiceCommand.cs (1)
src/Modules/Catalogs/Application/Commands/Service/UpdateServiceCommand.cs (1)
UpdateServiceCommand(12-21)
src/Modules/ServiceCatalogs/API/Endpoints/Service/GetServiceByIdEndpoint.cs (3)
src/Shared/Endpoints/BaseEndpoint.cs (1)
BaseEndpoint(10-130)src/Modules/ServiceCatalogs/API/Endpoints/Service/CreateServiceEndpoint.cs (2)
Map(18-23)Task(25-37)src/Modules/ServiceCatalogs/API/Endpoints/ServiceCategory/GetServiceCategoryByIdEndpoint.cs (2)
Map(15-20)Task(22-35)
src/Modules/ServiceCatalogs/API/Endpoints/ServiceCategory/DeactivateServiceCategoryEndpoint.cs (2)
src/Shared/Endpoints/BaseEndpoint.cs (1)
BaseEndpoint(10-130)src/Modules/ServiceCatalogs/API/Endpoints/ServiceCategory/ActivateServiceCategoryEndpoint.cs (2)
Map(14-19)Task(21-29)
src/Modules/ServiceCatalogs/API/Endpoints/Service/ValidateServicesEndpoint.cs (2)
src/Shared/Endpoints/BaseEndpoint.cs (1)
BaseEndpoint(10-130)src/Shared/Contracts/Response.cs (1)
Response(12-20)
src/Modules/ServiceCatalogs/Application/Commands/Service/CreateServiceCommand.cs
Show resolved
Hide resolved
src/Modules/ServiceCatalogs/Application/Commands/Service/DeleteServiceCommand.cs
Show resolved
Hide resolved
src/Modules/ServiceCatalogs/Application/DTOs/Requests/Service/ValidateServicesResponse.cs
Outdated
Show resolved
Hide resolved
…rary DTOs for Phase 1b - Replace duplicate Application project GUID with unique GUID (A7B8C9D0-1E2F-3A4B-5C6D-7E8F9A0B1C2D) - Replace duplicate API project GUID with unique GUID (B1C2D3E4-F5A6-7B8C-9D0E-1F2A3B4C5D6E) - Update all GUID references in GlobalSection(ProjectConfigurationPlatforms) - Update all GUID references in GlobalSection(NestedProjects) - Add DisplayOrder validation in CreateServiceCommandHandler (cannot be negative) - Update DeleteServiceCommand documentation about soft-delete pattern (future enhancement) - Make ValidateServicesResponse collections non-nullable with required modifier and constructor validation - Comment shared contract imports (will be added in Phase 2) - Create temporary module DTOs to allow compilation without breaking module API pattern - Update Extensions.cs to register ServiceCatalogsModuleApi without interface (Phase 2)
- Add XML documentation to all queries, commands, and requests for consistency - Extract duplicate DTO mapping logic to DtoMappingExtensions class - Use ToDto() and ToListDto() extension methods in all query handlers - Improve migration logging: warn when DbContext not found, log test environment skips - Treat Guid.Empty as validation error in GetServiceByIdQueryHandler (consistency with commands) - Add explicit null check in CreateServiceCategoryEndpoint for safer handling - Centralize mapping logic to avoid duplication and improve maintainability
- Add missing DisplayOrder parameter to ModuleServiceDto constructors - Fix ModuleServiceListDto constructor parameter order - Remove 'required' modifier from ValidateServicesResponse properties (conflicts with constructor) - Update ValidateServicesEndpoint to use concrete ServiceCatalogsModuleApi type
There was a problem hiding this comment.
Actionable comments posted: 2
♻️ Duplicate comments (1)
src/Modules/ServiceCatalogs/Application/Commands/Service/DeleteServiceCommand.cs (1)
6-11: Documentation added, but implementation still pending.The XML comment is a positive step in documenting the known limitation. However, the core issue flagged in the previous review remains unaddressed—the command still enables hard deletion without referential integrity validation.
The handler needs one of the previously suggested implementations:
- Pre-deletion check via
IProvidersModuleApito prevent orphaned records- Soft-delete pattern (
IsActive = false) consistent with Users/Providers modules- Integration tests covering the deletion scenario
Is there a tracking issue for this work, or is it planned for a follow-up PR?
🧹 Nitpick comments (5)
src/Modules/ServiceCatalogs/Application/Commands/ServiceCategory/UpdateServiceCategoryCommand.cs (1)
9-14: Consider whether partial updates would be more appropriate.This command requires all fields for updates. Depending on API requirements, you might want to support partial updates where clients only send changed fields. This can be achieved by making all update fields nullable or using a different pattern (e.g., optional wrapper types).
src/Modules/ServiceCatalogs/Application/Mappings/DtoMappingExtensions.cs (1)
1-35: Centralized DTO mappings are accurate and helpfulThe
ToListDto(Service)andToDto(ServiceCategory)mappings correctly reflect the DTO shapes and nicely centralize conversion logic, reducing duplication across handlers.src/Modules/ServiceCatalogs/Application/Handlers/Queries/Service/GetServiceByIdQueryHandler.cs (1)
31-41: Consider using a mapping extension for consistency.This handler manually constructs the
ServiceDto, whileGetServiceCategoryByIdQueryHandler(line 27) uses aToDto()extension method. Using a consistent mapping approach reduces duplication and maintenance burden.If a mapping extension doesn't exist for Service entities, consider adding one in
DtoMappingExtensions.cs:public static ServiceDto ToDto(this Service service) { var categoryName = service.Category?.Name ?? ValidationMessages.Catalogs.UnknownCategoryName; return new ServiceDto( service.Id.Value, service.CategoryId.Value, categoryName, service.Name, service.Description, service.IsActive, service.DisplayOrder, service.CreatedAt, service.UpdatedAt ); }Then simplify the handler:
- var dto = new ServiceDto( - service.Id.Value, - service.CategoryId.Value, - categoryName, - service.Name, - service.Description, - service.IsActive, - service.DisplayOrder, - service.CreatedAt, - service.UpdatedAt - ); + var dto = service.ToDto();src/Modules/ServiceCatalogs/Application/ModuleApi/TemporaryModuleDtos.cs (1)
1-47: LGTM - well-documented temporary solution.The temporary DTOs are appropriately documented for Phase 1b compilation, with clear TODO comments indicating they'll be replaced by shared contracts in Phase 2. The simple record types provide clean data contracts for the module API.
Do you want me to create a tracking issue for the Phase 2 work to replace these temporary DTOs with shared contracts?
src/Modules/ServiceCatalogs/Application/ModuleApi/ServiceCatalogsModuleApi.cs (1)
76-82: Manual DTO construction is acceptable for temporary DTOs.All methods manually construct the temporary Module DTOs inline. While this creates some duplication, it's acceptable given:
- These are temporary DTOs (Phase 1b) that will be replaced by shared contracts in Phase 2
- The Module API uses different DTO types than the Application layer
- The mapping logic is straightforward
Once shared contracts are introduced in Phase 2, consider using dedicated mapping extensions to reduce duplication.
Also applies to: 101-107, 135-143, 162-167, 191-199
📜 Review details
Configuration used: CodeRabbit UI
Review profile: CHILL
Plan: Pro
📒 Files selected for processing (22)
MeAjudaAi.sln(4 hunks)src/Modules/ServiceCatalogs/API/Endpoints/Service/ValidateServicesEndpoint.cs(1 hunks)src/Modules/ServiceCatalogs/API/Endpoints/ServiceCategory/CreateServiceCategoryEndpoint.cs(1 hunks)src/Modules/ServiceCatalogs/API/Extensions.cs(1 hunks)src/Modules/ServiceCatalogs/Application/Commands/Service/DeleteServiceCommand.cs(1 hunks)src/Modules/ServiceCatalogs/Application/Commands/ServiceCategory/ActivateServiceCategoryCommand.cs(1 hunks)src/Modules/ServiceCatalogs/Application/Commands/ServiceCategory/UpdateServiceCategoryCommand.cs(1 hunks)src/Modules/ServiceCatalogs/Application/DTOs/Requests/Service/UpdateServiceRequest.cs(1 hunks)src/Modules/ServiceCatalogs/Application/DTOs/Requests/Service/ValidateServicesResponse.cs(1 hunks)src/Modules/ServiceCatalogs/Application/Extensions.cs(1 hunks)src/Modules/ServiceCatalogs/Application/Handlers/Commands/Service/CreateServiceCommandHandler.cs(1 hunks)src/Modules/ServiceCatalogs/Application/Handlers/Queries/Service/GetAllServicesQueryHandler.cs(1 hunks)src/Modules/ServiceCatalogs/Application/Handlers/Queries/Service/GetServiceByIdQueryHandler.cs(1 hunks)src/Modules/ServiceCatalogs/Application/Handlers/Queries/Service/GetServicesByCategoryQueryHandler.cs(1 hunks)src/Modules/ServiceCatalogs/Application/Handlers/Queries/ServiceCategory/GetAllServiceCategoriesQueryHandler.cs(1 hunks)src/Modules/ServiceCatalogs/Application/Handlers/Queries/ServiceCategory/GetServiceCategoryByIdQueryHandler.cs(1 hunks)src/Modules/ServiceCatalogs/Application/Mappings/DtoMappingExtensions.cs(1 hunks)src/Modules/ServiceCatalogs/Application/ModuleApi/ServiceCatalogsModuleApi.cs(1 hunks)src/Modules/ServiceCatalogs/Application/ModuleApi/TemporaryModuleDtos.cs(1 hunks)src/Modules/ServiceCatalogs/Application/Queries/Service/GetServicesByCategoryQuery.cs(1 hunks)src/Modules/ServiceCatalogs/Application/Queries/ServiceCategory/GetServiceCategoriesWithCountQuery.cs(1 hunks)src/Modules/ServiceCatalogs/Application/Queries/ServiceCategory/GetServiceCategoryByIdQuery.cs(1 hunks)
🚧 Files skipped from review as they are similar to previous changes (9)
- src/Modules/ServiceCatalogs/Application/Commands/ServiceCategory/ActivateServiceCategoryCommand.cs
- src/Modules/ServiceCatalogs/Application/DTOs/Requests/Service/UpdateServiceRequest.cs
- src/Modules/ServiceCatalogs/Application/Queries/Service/GetServicesByCategoryQuery.cs
- src/Modules/ServiceCatalogs/Application/Handlers/Queries/Service/GetAllServicesQueryHandler.cs
- src/Modules/ServiceCatalogs/Application/Handlers/Queries/ServiceCategory/GetAllServiceCategoriesQueryHandler.cs
- src/Modules/ServiceCatalogs/Application/DTOs/Requests/Service/ValidateServicesResponse.cs
- src/Modules/ServiceCatalogs/Application/Handlers/Queries/Service/GetServicesByCategoryQueryHandler.cs
- src/Modules/ServiceCatalogs/Application/Extensions.cs
- src/Modules/ServiceCatalogs/API/Endpoints/ServiceCategory/CreateServiceCategoryEndpoint.cs
🧰 Additional context used
🧬 Code graph analysis (8)
src/Modules/ServiceCatalogs/Application/ModuleApi/TemporaryModuleDtos.cs (1)
src/Modules/ServiceCatalogs/Application/ModuleApi/ServiceCatalogsModuleApi.cs (1)
ModuleApi(22-308)
src/Modules/ServiceCatalogs/Application/Handlers/Queries/ServiceCategory/GetServiceCategoryByIdQueryHandler.cs (2)
src/Modules/ServiceCatalogs/Application/Mappings/DtoMappingExtensions.cs (1)
ServiceCategoryDto(26-34)src/Modules/ServiceCatalogs/Application/Handlers/Queries/Service/GetServiceByIdQueryHandler.cs (1)
Task(14-44)
src/Modules/ServiceCatalogs/API/Extensions.cs (2)
src/Modules/ServiceCatalogs/Application/Extensions.cs (2)
Extensions(8-22)IServiceCollection(10-21)src/Modules/ServiceCatalogs/API/Endpoints/ServiceCatalogsModuleEndpoints.cs (1)
MapServiceCatalogsEndpoints(17-43)
src/Modules/ServiceCatalogs/Application/Handlers/Queries/Service/GetServiceByIdQueryHandler.cs (4)
src/Modules/ServiceCatalogs/Application/ModuleApi/ServiceCatalogsModuleApi.cs (8)
Task(37-59)Task(61-91)Task(93-116)Task(118-152)Task(154-176)Task(178-208)Task(210-233)Task(235-307)src/Modules/ServiceCatalogs/Application/Handlers/Queries/ServiceCategory/GetServiceCategoryByIdQueryHandler.cs (1)
Task(14-30)src/Shared/Constants/ValidationMessages.cs (2)
ValidationMessages(9-90)Catalogs(83-89)src/Modules/Catalogs/Application/Handlers/Queries/QueryHandlers.cs (1)
GetServiceByIdQueryHandler(15-45)
src/Modules/ServiceCatalogs/Application/Handlers/Commands/Service/CreateServiceCommandHandler.cs (2)
src/Modules/ServiceCatalogs/Application/Handlers/Queries/Service/GetServiceByIdQueryHandler.cs (1)
Task(14-44)src/Modules/Catalogs/Application/Handlers/Commands/CommandHandlers.cs (1)
CreateServiceCommandHandler(162-210)
src/Modules/ServiceCatalogs/Application/Queries/ServiceCategory/GetServiceCategoryByIdQuery.cs (1)
src/Modules/ServiceCatalogs/Application/Mappings/DtoMappingExtensions.cs (1)
ServiceCategoryDto(26-34)
src/Modules/ServiceCatalogs/API/Endpoints/Service/ValidateServicesEndpoint.cs (3)
src/Modules/ServiceCatalogs/Application/ModuleApi/ServiceCatalogsModuleApi.cs (9)
ModuleApi(22-308)Task(37-59)Task(61-91)Task(93-116)Task(118-152)Task(154-176)Task(178-208)Task(210-233)Task(235-307)src/Shared/Endpoints/BaseEndpoint.cs (1)
BaseEndpoint(10-130)src/Modules/ServiceCatalogs/Application/DTOs/Requests/Service/ValidateServicesResponse.cs (1)
ValidateServicesResponse(9-14)
src/Modules/ServiceCatalogs/Application/ModuleApi/ServiceCatalogsModuleApi.cs (4)
src/Modules/ServiceCatalogs/API/Extensions.cs (1)
Extensions(13-94)src/Modules/ServiceCatalogs/Application/Extensions.cs (1)
Extensions(8-22)src/Modules/ServiceCatalogs/API/Endpoints/Service/ValidateServicesEndpoint.cs (1)
Task(25-43)src/Shared/Constants/ValidationMessages.cs (2)
ValidationMessages(9-90)Catalogs(83-89)
⏰ Context from checks skipped due to timeout of 90000ms. You can increase the timeout in your CodeRabbit configuration to a maximum of 15 minutes (900000ms). (2)
- GitHub Check: Code Quality Checks
- GitHub Check: Security Scan
🔇 Additional comments (10)
src/Modules/ServiceCatalogs/Application/Commands/ServiceCategory/UpdateServiceCategoryCommand.cs (1)
9-14: No action required — validation is properly implemented.Input validation for
UpdateServiceCategoryCommandis already in place at both the handler and domain levels. The handler validates thatNameis not null/whitespace and thatDisplayOrdercannot be negative (via the domain'sValidateDisplayOrdermethod, which throws if the value is less than 0). Description length is also constrained. The command design is correct.src/Modules/ServiceCatalogs/Application/Queries/ServiceCategory/GetServiceCategoriesWithCountQuery.cs (1)
1-11: Query contract looks consistent and clearThe record shape, default
ActiveOnlyflag, and baseQuery<Result<IReadOnlyList<ServiceCategoryWithCountDto>>>align well with the existing CQRS patterns. No issues spotted here.MeAjudaAi.sln (1)
148-165: ServiceCatalogs solution wiring and GUID usage look correctThe new ServiceCatalogs folders and projects are wired consistently:
- Folders use
{44577491-2FC0-4F52-AF5C-2BC9B323CDB7}(Application) and{30A2D3C4-AF98-40A1-AA90-ED7C5FE090F8}(API), while the corresponding projects use distinct GUIDs{A7B8C9D0-1E2F-3A4B-5C6D-7E8F9A0B1C2D}and{B1C2D3E4-F5A6-7B8C-9D0E-1F2A3B4C5D6E}, removing the earlier folder/project GUID collisions.- Both project GUIDs are fully represented in
ProjectConfigurationPlatformsand correctly nested under the ServiceCatalogs hierarchy inNestedProjects.This should load and build cleanly in Visual Studio/MSBuild.
Also applies to: 584-595, 608-619, 694-699
src/Modules/ServiceCatalogs/Application/Handlers/Commands/Service/CreateServiceCommandHandler.cs (1)
12-68: Create service handler is consistent and well‑validatedThe handler mirrors the previous Catalogs behavior while improving on it (name trimming plus explicit non‑negative
DisplayOrdervalidation). Category checks, duplicate name verification, and DTO mapping all look correct and aligned with the rest of the module.src/Modules/ServiceCatalogs/Application/Queries/ServiceCategory/GetServiceCategoryByIdQuery.cs (1)
1-11: Id‑based category query matches existing CQRS conventionsThe query shape (
Guid Id→Query<Result<ServiceCategoryDto?>>) and namespace are consistent with other queries and handlers in the ServiceCatalogs module. Looks good.src/Modules/ServiceCatalogs/API/Extensions.cs (1)
13-93: Module registration and migration strategy look solid
AddServiceCatalogsModuleandUseServiceCatalogsModuleprovide a clean entry point for wiring the module, andEnsureDatabaseMigrations:
- Skips automatic migrations in explicit test environments.
- Applies
Database.Migrate()by default.- Falls back to
EnsureCreated()only in Development, while still failing fast if both steps fail.As long as the host app calls
AddServiceCatalogsModulebeforeUseServiceCatalogsModuleand uses the same"Test"/"Testing"environment names, this should behave as intended.src/Modules/ServiceCatalogs/Application/Handlers/Queries/Service/GetServiceByIdQueryHandler.cs (1)
18-20: LGTM - appropriate validation error handling.The Guid.Empty validation correctly returns a
Failureresult, which is the appropriate approach for input validation errors. This aligns with the ModuleApi methods and provides clear error semantics.src/Modules/ServiceCatalogs/Application/ModuleApi/ServiceCatalogsModuleApi.cs (3)
37-59: LGTM - robust health check implementation.The availability check appropriately tests database connectivity, handles cancellation correctly by rethrowing
OperationCanceledException, and gracefully returnsfalsefor other exceptions. Logging is adequate for troubleshooting.
235-307: LGTM - excellent validation implementation with N+1 prevention.The batch validation method demonstrates several best practices:
- Proper null and empty collection handling with short-circuit
- Input deduplication to avoid redundant queries
- Batch query via
GetByIdsAsync(line 276) to prevent N+1 performance issues- Clear separation of invalid (not found) vs inactive service IDs
This is a well-optimized implementation for bulk validation scenarios.
133-133: The original review comment raised an unfounded concern. Repository implementations across both modules (ServiceCatalogs and Catalogs) consistently load the Category navigation property using.Include(s => s.Category)in all query methods (GetByIdAsync,GetByIdsAsync,GetByNameAsync,GetAllAsync, andGetByCategoryAsync). The null coalescing operator in the code at lines 133 and 194 correctly handles null safety; it will not default toUnknownCategoryNameunder normal operation.Likely an incorrect or invalid review comment.
src/Modules/ServiceCatalogs/API/Endpoints/Service/ValidateServicesEndpoint.cs
Show resolved
Hide resolved
...eCatalogs/Application/Handlers/Queries/ServiceCategory/GetServiceCategoryByIdQueryHandler.cs
Outdated
Show resolved
Hide resolved
- Fix ValidateServicesEndpoint to use relative route 'validate' instead of absolute '/validate'
so it registers under versioned services group (/api/v{version}/catalogs/services/validate)
- Change GetServiceCategoryByIdQueryHandler to return Failure for Guid.Empty instead of Success(null)
for consistency with GetServiceByIdQueryHandler
- Add Service.ToDto() extension method to DtoMappingExtensions for centralized mapping
- Refactor GetServiceByIdQueryHandler to use Service.ToDto() extension method instead of manual construction
- Add XML documentation to UpdateServiceCategoryCommand noting full-update pattern and future partial update consideration
📊 Code Coverage ReportCoverage: 40.51% (extracted from OpenCover (Direct)) 📈 Coverage Details
📋 Coverage Analysis
🎯 Quality Gates
📁 Artifacts
This comment is updated automatically on each push to track coverage trends. |
Summary by CodeRabbit