New button to disable lobby in sidebar

[PVince81]

Fixes #4981
Fixes #4982

Note: I tried adding more information like the remaining time until meeting start, but it would take too much space and make the sidebar look too crowded. Also the moment library doesn't generate nice compact human readable texts for remaining durations. So if we do want this: needs further research.

[marcoambrosini]

I don't think this button should be there. We could create a new action button in the moderation menu when the lobby is activated. That would make it for a 2 click operation, wouldn't it be enough? If not I would say we add a circular unlabeled button beside the moderation menu (only when the lobby is enabled)

[PVince81]

@ma12-co we should also fulfil #4982 which requires a way to find out whether the lobby is enabled without extra clicks. The button being present would already be a sign.

[nickvergessen]

I don't think this button should be there.

Only the disable is there and that must be. It must be really prominent and is mostly the next thing to be done in meetings.

[marcoambrosini]

What about

circular unlabeled button beside the moderation menu (only when the lobby is enabled)

[PVince81]

What about

circular unlabeled button beside the moderation menu (only when the lobby is enabled)

unlabeled with what icon ?

[nickvergessen]

Works and good enough for now

[marcoambrosini]

unlabeled with what icon ?

Maybe message lock?

[nickvergessen]

It needs to be super obvious. So if it's only an icon, it needs to be primary to make sure it's right into the eye.
But I think a labeled button is much better and more obvious.

[marcoambrosini]

it needs to be primary

I'd have suggested yellow (warning).

But I think a labeled button is much better and more obvious.

If you happen to have that part of the app visible at that given moment.

The main problem is that we're placing this button in an arbitrary place.

[nickvergessen]

unlabeled with what icon ?

Maybe message lock?

Or the lobby button, so it's obvious that it's the lobby...
https://github.com/nextcloud/spreed/blob/master/img/lobby.svg

[PVince81]

but clicking a button that looks like a bell doesn't tell me what the button does intuitively, so would need a tooltip to make it clear it's about disabling it, not enabling

[nickvergessen]

Well so as you can see in the ticket people have the sidebar open and check the participant list in such cases. So it's not arbitrary really.

[marcoambrosini]

but clicking a button that looks like a bell doesn't tell me what the button does intuitively, so would need a tooltip to make it clear it's about disabling it, not enabling

Agree on that a bell doesn't work. And for sure a tooltip would be needed!

I really don't like the design of it, but fine if you see it fit

[wiswedel]

Great implementation. Does exactly what it promises (and the wording refers 1:1 to the "enable" mechanism 👍).

[PVince81]

Let's move forward for now. We can iterate on the design later on when having another look bird's eye vue at the lobby feature.

[nickvergessen]

Icon in question is RoomService https://material.io/resources/icons/?search=service&icon=room_service&style=baseline